Cheese and Leek Toastie with Buttery Braised Leeks

This cheese and leek toastie is a combinations that makes you wonder why you haven’t been doing it for years. Buttery braised leeks go soft and sweet in the pan. Sharp mature cheddar brings the salt and the tang. Melted together between thick slices of sourdough, you get a toastie that eats like something off a good pub menu.

This is not a five minute sandwich, and that is the point. The leeks need time to collapse into something silky. Do that part properly and the rest takes minutes.

Why Slow Cooked Leeks Change Everything

Leeks cooked fast stay squeaky and a little raw. Leeks cooked slowly in butter turn into something closer to a confit, soft enough to melt into the cheese rather than sit next to it. Low and slow is the whole trick.

The leeks can be made well in advance, which makes this an easy lunch to pull together on a weekday.

Choosing Your Cheddar

Go sharp and go aged. Six months is the minimum for a Cheddar with enough character to stand up to butter and leeks, and twelve months is better still. A mild block cheddar will melt beautifully and taste of very little.

Do not skimp on the quantity either. You want the sandwich oozing at the edges when you cut into it.

The Bread Matters

Sourdough is my choice here. The chew and the slight sourness cut through all that butter. Cut the slices fairly thick, because they press down and flatten as they toast. That said, any decent bread will work.

Tips for the Best Cheese and Leek Toastie

Soften the butter for the outside of the bread to make spreading it easier.

Use white pepper instead of black, freshly ground. The flavour is more floral and I think it suits the leeks better.

Clean your leeks properly. Grit hides between the layers, so slice first, then rinse in a bowl of cold water and lift the leeks out rather than pouring them into a sieve.

Let the leeks cool before they go anywhere near the bread. Warm leeks make the bread soggy before it hits the heat.

I used a sandwich press, but a heavy frying pan with a weight on top, or a ridged griddle all work.

Substitutions and Variations

Gruyère or Comté in place of some of the cheddar gives you a nuttier, stretchier melt.

A thin scrape of Dijon or wholegrain mustard on the inside of the bread sharpens everything up, but this sandwich is equally as nice without it. If you do add it, just add the smaller amount so it doesn’t over power.

Crisp bacon or pancetta turns this into a much heavier lunch, in a good way.

Serving Suggestions

A mixed green salad with a mustardy dressing is all this needs. If you are serving these as a light supper, a bowl of soup is the obvious and correct answer.

Frequently Asked Questions for Cheese and Leek Toastie

Can I make the leeks ahead of time?

Yes, and I would recommend it. Cook them, cool them completely and keep them covered in the fridge for up to three days. Bring them to room temperature before assembling.

What can I use instead of a sandwich press?

A heavy frying pan works well. Cook the sandwich over medium-low heat and press it down with another pan or a flat lid so the cheese melts by the time the bread is golden. Flip once.

Why are my leeks watery?

They were probably cooked too fast, or still wet from washing. Dry them well after rinsing and keep the heat gentle so the moisture cooks off slowly rather than steaming out all at once.

Can I use frozen leeks?

You can, but they release more water. Cook them for longer and let the liquid evaporate fully before you take them off the heat.

Which part of the leek should I use?

The white and pale green parts. The dark green tops are tough here, though they are worth saving for stock.

What is the best bread for a toastie?

Sourdough for structure and flavour. A good white bloomer or a rustic country loaf also work. Avoid anything too soft or thinly sliced, because it collapses under the cheese.

More Recipes You’ll Love

The best French onion grilled cheese

Giant grilled cheese with hot honey butter

Classic South African Braaibroodjie Jaffle

‘Pizza’ Jaffles With Tomato, Mozzarella & Onion

Toasted Cheddar Cheese Sandwich With Buttery Leeks

Jalapeno popper grilled cheese sandwich with bacon

Caramelised pear and Gorgonzola toasties

BUY MY eBOOK COMFORT

 Find me on Instagram & Pinterest